Justia prop 36 waiver advisement of rights waiver and. We estimate that about 40,000 offenders annually are convicted of the above crimes and would be affected by the measure. Full text of california proposition 36 the substance abuse. To be completely honest i was unaware i had a choice in the matter i went to check in with my po last week and he told me i have to go to court on the 14th and that i will be supervised by the courts from now. In 2012, proposition 36 was passed, limiting the 25 years to life sentence to cases where the new felony offense was also a serious or violent crime. Wobblers are a special class of crimes involving conduct that varies widely in its level of seriousness, and therefore may be chargeable or. In november 2000, california voters passed proposition 36 prop 36, which was enacted into law as the substance abuse and crime prevention act of 2000.
Contains the full text of proposition 36 from the california secretary of states office. During both the pre and post prop 47 periods, these observable case characteristics explain nearly all of the observable race disparities in court dispositions. The proposition 47 list of specified prior convictions includes any serious andor violent felony offense punishable by life imprisonment or death. Proposition 36 in 2012, which revised californias threestrikes law, but the mandated target still was not met. In november 2014, another major reform, proposi tion 47 prop drug possession. Proposition 47s resentencing guidelines do not apply. How to evaluate a ballot measure some general tips on how to make up your mind about whether to vote yes or no. Comparative effectiveness of californias proposition 36 and. Hivaids prevalence in jails is four to six times higher than the national population. Proposition 47 is codified at california penal code 1170. California proposition 47, reduced penalties for some crimes. Proposition 36 institute of governmental studies uc berkeley.
Change crimes like purse and phone snatching where thieves grab expensive property right off your body into petty theft, the same as stealing a candy bar. Watch it here or watch the full election special here. Thereafter, on november 8, 1994, the voters approved proposition 184, which enacted a second version of the law by adding section 1170. However, we observe a narrowing of the disparities with the passage of prop 47. Simple possession per hs150a typically cocaine and heroin and hs177a typically meth are the two drug offenses that qualify. The latter law punishes habitual offenders by establishing sentence escalation for crimes that were classified as strikes, and requires a. Wobblers are a special class of crimes involving conduct that varies widely in its level of seriousness, and therefore may be chargeable or punishable as either a felony or a misdemeanor. Prop 36 waiver advisement of rights waiver and plea form form.
Proposition 36 institute of governmental studies uc. With some exceptions, proposition 36 modified californias three strikes law to reduce the punishment imposed when a defendants third felony conviction is. It should be emphasized, however, that until appellate courts weigh in on the specifics of proposition 47, much will be left to. Proposition 36, the substance abuse and crime prevention act sacpa, which was. The underlying premise of proposition 47 was to free up funds so the state could focus on violent and serious offenders. In 2014, california voters passed proposition 47, the safe neighborhood and. Since its passage 10 years ago by 61% of california voters, prop 36 has matured into an established criminal justice diversion option for offenders in all counties in the state, and in the past decade, more than 20 states have considered, and some have implemented, legislation that is similar to prop 36 the avisa group, 2005. Prop 47 also added a new crime of shoplifting, which formerly could be prosecuted as a theft or burglary charge, regardless of the amount of merchandise involved. For decades, californias tough stance on crime, including its threestrikes law, has contributed to a swelling inmate population. Nov 06, 2012 judges and prosecutors dont need proposition 36.
The ucla integrated substance abuse programs ucla has an interagency agreement with the department of alcohol and drug programs to conduct an independent evaluation. Under prop 36, adults convicted of nonviolent drug. A lack of funding for prop 36 treatment programs and controversies about county spending have posed obstacles to the laws implementation. The prison population declined further as a result of. Bradley oconnell assistant director, first district appellate project nov. Some offenders with two prior serious or violent felony convictions who are currently serving life sentences for many nonserious, nonviolent felony convictions could be resentenced to shorter prison terms. Proposition 47 prospectively reduces many theft and drug possession offenses from felonies or wobblers to straight misdemeanors.
Full text of california proposition 36 the substance. Specifically, prop 36 changed california law to require that first and secondtime defendants who have been convicted of nonviolent drug possession offenses receive up to twelve 12 months of substance abuse treatment instead of time in jail or prison. What is the impact of prop 57 on when persons in state prison may be released. The county jail adp rates and the rates of prop 47related prison releases are combined to create the total rate change in facility population postprop 47 to provide a single unit of comparison to countylevel crime. If prop 36s benefits had been extended retroactively, these people would have received them. Using proposition 47 to reduce convictions and restore rights. Proposition 36 is codified at california penal code 1170. This period may be extended by up to two 2 more six 6month periods if necessary. The data, reanalyzed by the mcintosh commission on fair play in studentathlete admissions, show that had prop. Proposition 36 petition for dismissal of charges cr75 this is a california form that can be used for criminal within local county, san mateo. As is the case in proposition 36, proposition 47 does not designate a specific. Even today, many defendants take advantage of prop.
Proposition 36 petition for dismissal of charges cr75. The effect of scaling back punishment on racial disparities. Proposition 47s resentencing guidelines do not apply to. Prop 47 reduced the penalties associated with a set of lowerlevel drug and prop. Accordingly, much of the appellate interpretation of proposition 36 is likely relevant in the interpretation of proposition 47. This new, separate crime penal code section 459a is defined as entering a commercial dwelling, such as a convenience store, while the establishment is open and during regular. Persons with a previous conviction for violent crimes such as rape, murder, or child molestation would receive felony sentences. This initiative measure is submitted to the people in accordance with the provisions of section 8 of article ii of the california constitution this initiative measure amends and adds sections to the penal code. Characteristics of prop 36 clients entering treatment during fy 200607 by county 328.
If proposition 36 passes, about 3,000 convicted felons. In fact, it reduces our ability to use three strikes to target dangerous repeat felons and get them off the streets once and for all. Resentencing under californias proposition 47 nolo. If prop 36 s benefits had been extended retroactively, these people would have received them. Whereas the baseline penalty for felony drug possession in california ranges from 16 months to 3 years,11 proposition 36 allows people convicted of. Comparative effectiveness of californias proposition 36. Only certain offenses qualify for reduction under prop. Proposition 36 wasnt passed without a lot of controversy, and the program continues to face threats from its opponents. Proposition 47 would alter the law by requiring misdemeanor sentences instead of felonies for certain nonserious crimes. Get the facts over a dozen proposition 36 fact sheets are available for download. Prop 47 quick reference charge misdemeanor felony hs 150a. Some of the notsoobvious things prop 47 will do are. Savings would be diverted to schoolbased prevention and support programs.
The county jail adp rates and the rates of prop 47 related prison releases are combined to create the total rate change in facility population post prop 47 to provide a single unit of comparison to countylevel crime. Families of some threestrikers hope for early release or shorter sentences, san jose mercury news, nov. On november 8, 2016, california voters passed proposition. Californias correctional challenge, and proposition 36. Austin, jfa institute, correspondence, february 6, 2006. The impact of proposition 47 on crime and recidivism. Proposition 36 three strikes reform preliminary analysis and suggested approach for appellate attorneys j. Resource page to visit what electors supported aka ab109, prop 36, ca prop 47.
Prior to the enactment of proposition 36, the essence of the three strikes was to require a defendant law convicted of any new felony, having suffered one prior conviction of seriouas felony as. Prop 47 and crime in 2015 center on juvenile and criminal. Proposition 47 rendered all violations of section 496 that do not. Nov 04, 2014 prop 47 is a lengthy piece of legislation with many hidden provisions. Sample briefing on proposition 47 s impact on health and safety code sections 152 and 179 sample brief provided curtesy of panel attorney. The complete text of the initiative is attached separately. For additional information about proposition 47 issues, click on the prop. On november 7, 2012, the california voters approved proposition 36, entitled the three strikes reform act of 2012. Proposition 36, the substance abuse and crime prevention act sacpa, which was enacted through initiative process with the support of 61 percent of california voters in november 2000. Persons now serving felony sentences for these crimes would be resentenced unless court can articulate unreasonable safety risks. Proposition 47 both parallels and interlocks with proposition 36. Ventura county proposition 36 implementation 5 methodology this report highlights the discretionary aspects of prop 36 implementation and makes recommendations on ventura county policy decisions that directly influence the effectiveness, costs, public safety, and public perception of prop 36. Proposition 36 proposition 36 2012 revised the states threestrikes law to permit resentencing for qualifying thirdstrike inmates whose third strike was not serious or violent.
Mar 23, 2017 california proposition 36, the substance abuse and crime prevention act of 2000, went into effect in 2001 after 60. Californias proposition 36 the pros and cons of prop 36. Now, thanks to proposition 47 many drug offenses are misdemeanors, but when prop. This cheat sheet was published in tandem with a prop 47 segment on kcet s socal connected. National families in action a guide to drugrelated state ballot initiatives. Proposition 36, also titled a change in the three strikes law initiative, was a california ballot measure that was passed in november 2012 to modify californias three strikes law passed in 1994. On november 4, 2014, california voters passed proposition 47 prop 47. How will prop 47 affect a prop 36 sentence to be completely honest i was unaware i had a choice in the matter i went to check in with my po last week and he told me i have to go to court on the 14th. Possession of heroincocaine, etc 1 year max super strike or pc 290c hs 157a possession of concentrated cannabis 1 year max super strike or pc 290c hs 177a possession of methamphetamine, etc 1 year max super strike or pc 290c pc 459. Please click on the samples tab above to view collected sample arguments as they become available. The safe neighborhoods and schools act, proposition 47 on the november 2014. They had to get counsel appointed after denial of the original petition do to the complexities of the issues when they appealed the lower court decision. This area of our site offers project analysis of prop 36 and its potential application to current or former clients. Proposition 36, the essence of the three strikes law was to require a defendant.
794 377 382 186 849 108 1013 873 1202 988 572 680 1166 911 333 772 560 818 493 623 10 398 394 64 1012 1522 506 1536 1542 448 851 1605 1323 1385 35 1384 693 681 1332 684 391 1457 574 1255